Sign up today and take advantage of member-only content — the kind of timely, cutting edge industry insight that only Money Management Executive can deliver.
  • Exclusive Online Only Content
  • Free Daily Email News Alerts
  • Asset Management Blogs

Fund Forward

For 401(k)s, Too Safe Can Sometimes Lead to Sorry

Score one for the mutual fund industry.

It isn't every day that two influential consumer groups, the Consumer Federation of America and Fund Democracy, rally to the industry's support. But that's precisely what happened last Monday when they fired off a letter to the Office of Management and Budget, urging it to ignore protestations from the insurance industry to extend default 401(k) options the Department of Labor has proposed.

In response to the Pension Protection Act, which encourages employers to automatically steer new employees who fail to sign up for a 401(k) into default choices, the DOL has suggested balanced and target-date funds. But the American Council of Life Insurers wants the defaults to also include stable-value funds, money market funds, guaranteed investment contracts and other types of capital preservation funds. It's no wonder the insurance industry is going to the mattresses on this. Stable-value funds accounted for 13%, or $400 billion, of 401(k) investments in 2005, according to data from the Employee Benefit Research Institute and the Stable Value Investment Association.

In their letter to the OMB last Monday, in which the Consumer Federation and Fund Democracy ask the OMB to support the DOL, the two groups call permitting stable-value funds a "mattress mentality" and the insurance industry's support of them a "self-interested argument."

Citing data from the ICI, the two groups reason that a person who begins investing in a target-date fund at age 30 would have an account twice as big by the time they retire than if they had invested in a stable-value fund.

"It is widely accepted that, if capital preservation vehicles are included as qualified default investments, they will be adopted by far too many employers and will attract a disproportionate percentage of retirement assets," the groups wrote. "Why should an employer take greater litigation risk on a default option such as a lifecycle fund that may lose money in the short term when it can enjoy a liability safe harbor with a capital preservation investment? Their employees will be worse off, but their litigation exposure will be materially reduced.

"This is precisely why such a large percentage of plan sponsors have used capital preservation funds as default options. In short, including stable value as default options would leave millions of Americans poorer during their retirement years."

Certainly, I would agree that the default options the DOL is proposing are far better choices.

(c) 2007 Money Management Executive and SourceMedia, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

http://www.mmexecutive.com http://www.sourcemedia.com

Recent Posts

Mutual Funds Must Go High-Tech-v. 3.0

Over the last number of years, mutual fund transfer agencies and shareholder communications companies have tried to convince shareholders to accept paperless summary prospectuses, proxies, trade confirmations and electronically stamped signatures. Fund supermarkets and web home pages have broadened their horizons to include market commentary, videostreaming and personal financial news. At the same time, exchange-traded funds, funds-of-funds, hedge FoFs, unified managed accounts, target dates, 401(k) auto enrollment and heightened awareness among people throughout the country of the difficulties of being retired-have taken off.

Test of the Massey Mine

Fund giant boards of directors at AllianceBernstein, American Funds, Fidelity, Vanguard and others are reportedly starting to bring about meaningful change in the corporations in which they are invested. Proof should come any day now, when the shareholder proxy votes from the annual meetings are released. Fund chief executive officers spoke about the power and influence their proxies wield in an interesting Reuters article last week, "Mutual Funds Seek to Shed 'Rubber Stamp' Tag."

Milestones

In 2011, 401(k) plans will turn 30, but the milestones the mutual fund industry has reached in this time are but a nanosecond in the history of U.S. retirement policy. Executives we interviewed for this special edition of Money Management Executive for the Investment Company Institute's meeting in Washington, speak to important milestones of the recent past and into the future. Look inside for observations and forecasts by Ted Benna, Robert L. Reynolds, Dan Fuss, David C. John, Steven Miyao and others.

At Age 30, It's Time for a Revamping for the 401(k)

This year marks the 30th anniversary of the 401(k), the revolutionary retirement savings vehicle that has been annihilating pension plans, empowering individuals to take part in the stock market-and, sadly, that left retirees with the misfortune of leaving the workforce in 2000 or 2008 very badly off. The cracks in the system are prompting many asset managers, regulators and retirement experts to take a hard look at 401(k)s and how they can be fixed.

Index of Posts

49 Comments

Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty blog with me. I am appreciating it very much! Birkenstock sandals are usually an excellent fashionable shoes selection. Even though sandals are extremely related to summer season, they are able to be put on throughout other seasons.Many people normally have on the Birkenstock sandals in your house, while using the slip-on type of sandals specially favorite. The location in your geographical area, plus correctly,element, is certainly heading to aid determine if this is it will be heated plenty of make use of some sort of two of Birkenstock sandals out of doors.Putting on a pair of socks with the Birkenstock sandals happens to be an decisionmeant for less hot days. In case one are likely to be rather striking as part of your design phrases, consider you being dressed in male your own Cheap birkenstock sandals using a exciting coloring style and design sock. You can easily show men and women whom that you are bankruptcy lawyer las vegas dress in shoes.Birkenstock Sandal Variations. Many families love a strong easy-to-wear, comfortable running shoe, just what exactly you have when you decide to order just about any set of two Birkenstock shoes. Generally there may be a number of kinds of the widely accepted slip-on sandal, pertaining to either both males and females,which might oftentimes cause it to be extremely a complicated decision if deciding which pair to buy.

Posted by: xyzhen l | June 5, 2012 10:16 PM


Decorative painting and landscape painting, art paintings for sale have a high artistic level and ornamental value.abstract art paintings We can Glimpse from the style of beauty and local culture, experience the exoticcustoms.art deco paintings Composition layout of the whole painting light and dark has caused exude amood, ie,art paintings dense and thick, colorful, gleaming, makes the whole picture and intricate,beautiful, give a sense of the people relaxed and happy. http://www.artforsalecheap.com/

Posted by: jiade j | May 14, 2012 3:10 AM


The NBA announced the first annual awards. NBA Shop The SAN Antonio spurs coach gregg popovich won NBA2011-12 season of "the best coach". Tracy Mcgrady Shoes Gregg popovich led the spurs veterans staged the lockout-shortened season "miracles", Zoom Kobe 7 Shoes in the western conference amongst the elite is obtained in the top of the charts the regular season record. kobe zoom 6 At the same time, the spurs also created the continuous 15 season NBA playoff record of march.

Posted by: jiade j | May 14, 2012 3:09 AM


In particular, products from coach factory outlet with leather design are fashionable, handmade,leading the wave of American pop.It with simple,durable and unique style to win consumers.The coach factory online make no guarantees to their inventory so you may lose a really great deal or style simply because you did not act.To find a Coach Bag of any size, color or style to fit your needs at the coach factory outlet online is a very necessary thing for every beautiful woman.

Posted by: yan l | May 4, 2012 9:27 PM


My sister is working in the Burberry Outlet Stores, she said that they don't have the Burberry Outlet Online website at all ,all of the webiste that are selling Cheap Burberry Handbags are not real ,they may be selling the copys of burberry with high quality.

Posted by: damon g | March 19, 2012 10:30 PM


The brand names who specialise in just Moncler Mens Coats are growing in popularity and noteriety, and New Moncler Down Jackets are widely offered on the web and in selected large Moncler Women Jackets. 1 well recognized French brand name is 'Weekend a la Mer', and they offer you a smaller but stylish and sophisticated Moncler Mens Jackets. Being a French brand Discount Moncler Mens they certainly offer both warmer selections for the Winter via to Spring months, as well as http://www.monclermenstore.com/.

Posted by: feg g | January 4, 2012 7:59 PM


and will not flake no lack of nike air max good games for the team to work with them had to be.In addition, a business reporter Alan Brettman check with the Nike and Adidas are doing well to find and footwear sales.On the other hand, Deseret News' Jody Genessy jazz into it heavily slanted timjjokeuro possible to be a small market air max pas cher needs, and then writes that the CBA take a lot of Salt Lake City.

Posted by: fds d | January 4, 2012 12:35 AM


Mulberry Bags are hot sale with free shipping in Mulberry Outlet Store. Welcome you come here,come our uggs outlet stores. ugg outlet stores is the best stores of ugg boots outlet,offer all kinds of cheap ugg sale. Ugg outlet store sales various of discount uggs products,including boots, sandals, slipper, welcome to ugg outlet store to buy high quality products. Buy Mulberry Bags enjoy top fashion and save up to 70% off now. Discount Mulberry bags sale,Mulberry Outlet.Buy Mulberry bags from our Mulberry factory shop outlet! 70%Off Mulberry Bags, Mulberry Sale, Mulberry Purses, Mulberry Alexa, Mulberry Bayswater,Top Quality Free Shipping

Posted by: zzz f | December 22, 2011 8:00 PM


One classic type of Moncler Women is the windbreakers. These type of men's coats are wearable for all types of seasons. Moncler Winter Jacketst is made of fabric that could stand through time and it belongs to the category of light men's Moncler Boots. During winter season, these type of Moncler Coats Women could protect you from the chilling wind outside and at the same time warmth your body. And Moncler Jackets Men could also be wear during winter since it is made of lightweight materials which is warm for you to bear Moncler Coats Women.

Posted by: patrick2009 l | December 18, 2011 8:56 PM


The best men's Cheap Moncler coats are fashionable, affordable and keep you warm. Make sure you shop around when looking for your Moncler Vest Sale and you will find one that fits the Moncler Jackets UK. I have owned several throughout the years and have been pleased with every Moncler Mens Jackets purchase decision I have made. With an ever increasing number of designers Moncler Womens Jackets entering the market it is easier and easier to find a great pea coat for Moncler Coats Online.

Posted by: patrick2009 l | December 18, 2011 8:54 PM


Low Price Uggs On Sale, quality guarantee fashion Uggs Sale, safe shippment uggs on sale. Welcome to buy to have a warm winter and be fashion in winter. UGGs Outlet, UGGs On Sale, popular as well as good quality UGG Sale Online. Cheap ugg boots sale here,we promise you can get ugg boots at the lowest price,be quick! UGGs will company you all the winter. To keep warm is also important for men and kids. UGGs add warm to your feet and your heart.

Posted by: zzz f | December 5, 2011 11:58 PM


With a chic and unique design, New Moncler Down Jackets are also a viable option for you gentlemen. You can pair them with Moncler Mens Coats, a coloured scarf and a pair of moccasins that are terrific for a movie night. Moncler Women Jackets have that fluffy feel which transforms them in a highly comfortable Moncler Mens Jackets item. One Moncler Online Store cannot ignore their miraculous property of preserving the heat and bestowing upon the body the type of Discount Moncler Mens that is so indispensable in the http://www.monclermenstore.com/.

Posted by: feg g | November 25, 2011 11:20 PM


With a chic and unique design, New Moncler Down Jackets are also a viable option for you gentlemen. You can pair them with Moncler Mens Coats, a coloured scarf and a pair of moccasins that are terrific for a movie night. Moncler Women Jackets have that fluffy feel which transforms them in a highly comfortable Moncler Mens Jackets item. One Moncler Online Store cannot ignore their miraculous property of preserving the heat and bestowing upon the body the type of Discount Moncler Mens that is so indispensable in the http://www.monclermenstore.com/.

Posted by: feg g | November 25, 2011 11:19 PM


Why do I take an examination of tour guide, later to be a tour guide? mulberry outlet Want to be engaged in tourism industry after? Actually I also don't know, take an examination of this card is my personal interests, be is a employment chips to it, had from the moment the, I plan to learn, to the back, this year I have put this card scored, mulberry outlet uk the results on the road this out so many things, but those things are all is I want to do, and I can catch all take, committee on duty, lane association do agency exam psychological consultant. cheap mulberry A wide range of learning the more the better, eyebrows pushed beard, although busy although tired didn't entertainment time, didn't appreciate the autumn scenery of the time,mulberry handbags even the supermarket also haven't been to a few times, although not whether can do it better, but I very substantial, cheap mulberry handbags I get my youth these good time. To duck call her sister said just call me the dinner, the in the mind secretly pleased, mulberry sale hurriedly say good good results she says she is in the car didn't want to come back. So all the plans fell through all, inconsolable, really want to give Lao zhou a few box on the ear. spy4te

Posted by: zhan123 z | November 16, 2011 9:41 PM


Why do I take an examination of tour guide, later to be a tour guide? mulberry outlet Want to be engaged in tourism industry after? Actually I also don't know, take an examination of this card is my personal interests, be is a employment chips to it, had from the moment the, I plan to learn, to the back, this year I have put this card scored, mulberry outlet uk the results on the road this out so many things, but those things are all is I want to do, and I can catch all take, committee on duty, lane association do agency exam psychological consultant. cheap mulberry A wide range of learning the more the better, eyebrows pushed beard, although busy although tired didn't entertainment time, didn't appreciate the autumn scenery of the time,mulberry handbags even the supermarket also haven't been to a few times, although not whether can do it better, but I very substantial, cheap mulberry handbags I get my youth these good time. To duck call her sister said just call me the dinner, the in the mind secretly pleased, mulberry sale hurriedly say good good results she says she is in the car didn't want to come back. So all the plans fell through all, inconsolable, really want to give Lao zhou a few box on the ear. spy4te

Posted by: zhan123 z | November 16, 2011 9:40 PM


As stars favor, recently it also proceed onto the screen. Exposures in much more and much more magazines, Canada goose jackets distribute all much more compared to world. Supplied that it employed to skiing, some ski also rental Canada Goose Parka for people nowadays all much more compared to world. It has different sizes and colors for males and women, Canada Goose Canada  selling all much more compared to world. In some European countries, more youthful also go with on it for riding. Canada Goose Coats With trendy design, they are able to show their character everywhere, imitate stars who hold Canada Goose Sale within their shoulders, Canada Goose Jakke develop to be the synonym of masculinity. Canada Goose Mens Parka Canada Goose Expedition Parka Canada Goose Yorkville Parka Canada Goose Snow Mantra Parka Canada Goose Womens Parka Canada Goose Womens Expedition Canada Goose Chilliwack Parka Canada Goose Solaris Parka Canada Goose Trillium Parka Canada Goose Gloves

Posted by: qiu l | October 28, 2011 2:51 AM


Grimes the unit dvd before the oc dvd long the shield dvd studies the oz dvd that wild wild west dvd he's not the west wing dvd only west wing dvd in this the x files dvd suburban the wire dvd hellscape true blood dvd strewn two and a half men dvd with weeds dvd rotting will and grace dvd corpses, xena dvd soldiers beatles remastered dvd apparatus the beatles dvds and, of 007 dvd course, james bond dvd "walkers," 24 dvd the undead 30 rock dvd whose alias dvd chomp ally mcbeal dvd turns big love dvd humans bones dvd into brothers and sisters dvd bloodthirsty boston legal dvd zombies. http://boxsetszone.com

Posted by: ASDA A | October 5, 2011 10:10 PM


It's not yet clear the size of the womens clothes electorate Pawlenty frees up. GOP activists commonly praised his ladies dresses skill and background, but many were holding out until they met other candidates. This was designer dresses an especially common reaction among a class of designer clothes pro-business Republicans in Iowa.On paper, Pawlenty, 50, seemed to have all the women designer clothes right ingredients as a candidate.

Posted by: sdsd s | August 19, 2011 2:54 AM


Hours later, he reversed course in the face of rings a daunting challenge: convincing donors who were slow to give in the months charms leading up to the straw poll that he was still a viable candidate. Had he stayed in the bracelets race, he would have been competing for earrings money in an expanded field as Perry, a prolific fundraiser with deep ties to the party's necklaces biggest donors, entered the race.Said Pawlenty: "We weren't going to have the bangles fuel to keep the car going down the road."

Posted by: sdsd s | August 19, 2011 2:29 AM


Hours later, he reversed course in the face of rings a daunting challenge: convincing donors who were slow to give in the months charms leading up to the straw poll that he was still a viable candidate. Had he stayed in the bracelets race, he would have been competing for earrings money in an expanded field as Perry, a prolific fundraiser with deep ties to the party's necklaces biggest donors, entered the race.Said Pawlenty: "We weren't going to have the bangles fuel to keep the car going down the road."

Posted by: sdsd s | August 19, 2011 2:10 AM


Lee Barney

Lee Barney served as editor of Money Management Executive from 2002 to 2010. Previously, at United Media’s Wall Street & Technology magazine and Risk/Waters Information Services, she covered financial IT. For TheStreet.com, she wrote the daily “Meet the Street” column covering a broad spectrum of market-moving events. Lee began her career as a reporter in Tokyo with The Japan Times and was executive editor of Spotlight magazine.