Wells Fargo to Pay $11M in Wachovia CDO Case
April 11, 2011
Wells Fargo Securities will pay $11 million in penalties for misrepresentingâ€”and overcharging forâ€”two complex debt products tied to housing industry performance. The penalties were related to â€œmisconduct in the saleâ€ of two collateralized debt obligations, when the housing market was beginning to swoon in late 2006 and 2007. The conduct by Wachovia Capital Markets, as the unit then was known, violated securities laws in two ways, the SEC said.
First, Wachovia charged undisclosed excessive markups in the sale of certain preferred shares or equity of a CDO called Grand Avenue II to the Zuni Indian Tribe and an individual investor.
Wachovia marked down $5.5 million of equity to 52.7 cents on the dollar after the deal closed and it was unable to find a buyer. Later, an Indian tribe and an individual investor paid 90 cents and 95 cents on the dollar. The markups were more than 70% than what Wachovia said they were worth in its internal accounting.
Second, Wachovia misrepresented to investors in a CDO called Longshore 3 that it acquired assets from affiliates â€œon an armâ€™s-length basisâ€ and â€œat fair market prices.â€
Instead, 40 residential mortgage-backed securities were transferred from an affiliate at above-market prices, the SEC said. Wachovia transferred these assets at â€œstale prices, in order to avoid losses on its own books.â€
The SECâ€™s order does not find that Wachovia Capital Markets acted improperly otherwise in structuring the CDOs or in the way it described the roles played by those involved in the structuring process.
Wells Fargo Securities agreed to settle the SECâ€™s charges by paying more than $11 million in disgorgement and penalties, much of which will be returned to harmed investors.