Sign up today and take advantage of member-only content — the kind of timely, cutting edge industry insight that only Money Management Executive can deliver.
  • Exclusive Online Only Content
  • Free Daily Email News Alerts
  • Asset Management Blogs

Fund Scandal on Brink of Exploding


Those who have maintained the holier-than-thou attitude of the mutual fund industry and have believed that this scandal, too, shall pass, shouldn't kid themselves. It's time for the industry to turn in its halo.

New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer has maintained that the developments in his investigation involving corrupt deals between hedge funds and mutual funds is moving at a speed he has never seen before. Heads will roll, Spitzer has promised. Corporate crooks will be put behind bars for significant amounts of time, he's boasted.

Those who know Spitzer expect tough talk. However, New York's top regulator is not the only one talking about serious retribution.

"The industry has tried to say that this is not widespread," said Mercer Bullard, shareholder activist and former assistant chief counsel at the Securities and Exchange Commission. "I think we've reached a point where the number of firms implicated in one aspect or another indicates [the scandal] is widespread.

"In the complaint, you already have Janus, Bank of America, Bank One and Strong. Since then, you've had Merrill, Prudential, Alger and Alliance - all implicated one way or another. By anyone's definition, this is widespread in terms of the number of firms involved. And I think the number will continue to grow."

More than 80 firms in total have been subpoenaed. It is still unclear to what extent investors were harmed, although an academic report included in Spitzer's complaint indicated that market timing could diminish returns by 2%.

"The myth that the industry has somehow been a blessed industry where scandal could never happen or would never happen, is just out the window," said Don Phillips, managing director of Morningstar in Chicago. Phillips said there are two ways one could look at the developments: "The pessimistic view is, My God, this is just sprawling out of control.' Spitzer has basically said as much; this is going off in ways he didn't even anticipate.

"The more positive view is that the industry takes this extremely seriously and is rushing to clean up its act and purge any unethical behavior out of its system as quickly as possible."

However, Phillips added, market timing is moderately well spread out within the industry. There is some gray area as to what constitutes timing and when it is disadvantageous to long-term shareholders.

Kathryn Barland, a senior research analyst at Lipper, New York, believes the scandal is huge. Barland, who has worked in the enforcement division at the SEC and listing qualifications at Nasdaq, said it has been very frustrating for regulators dealing with the mutual fund industry in light of the opposition the industry gave to proxy voting disclosure, fees and expense disclosure, and even the Patriot Act. The industry has steadfastly maintained it has been flawless for 60 years and has questioned why regulators are pointing their fingers at them, Barland noted.

"I think it's beautiful that Eliot Spitzer has blown this thing wide open and made all those political arguments irrelevant. [He has] shown very clearly there is a problem in the mutual fund industry," she said.

However, not everyone is convinced of doom and gloom. "I think it's probably relatively limited," said Jeff McClure, a certified financial planner and author of The Personal Wealth Coach: Creating and Rebuilding Invested Wealth in the 21st Century. "When you look at the actual dollar damage that has been calculated, for example, by Bank of America, it's a relatively small number. Coming at the tail end of some of the other scandals, this will clean itself up rather quickly."

"Even the most serious and pessimistic view of this is that there are [only] a handful of funds doing this [involving] people at low levels" in most cases, McClure said.

Ed Moed, managing partner and co-founder of Peppercom, an international strategic communications firm headquartered in New York that specializes in crisis management for financial services firms, said the keys for firms involved in the scandal are: 1) unity among a firm's multiple departments, including sales, advertising, and legal, coming together to develop a united front and game plan; 2) persistence in cleaning up the wrongdoing; and 3) communicating that progress to shareholders.

"You can have a badly damaged reputation, but it's what you continue to do for the weeks and months after that to continue getting your house in order and communicating and being transparent and showing that you care that will get your reputation back."